Thursday, February 28, 2013

"Thieves in the Night", by Black Star

"Thieves in the Night" is a title of a track by Black Star who are a collaboration between Mos Def and Talib Kweli. This song was inspired by the themes/issues within "The Bluest Eye." 

"While Puff Daddy and his followers continued to dictate the direction hip-hop would take into the millennium, Mos Def and Talib Kweli surfaced from the underground to pull the sounds in the opposite direction. Their 13 rhyme fests on this superior, self-titled debut as Black Star show that old-school rap still sounds surprisingly fresh in the sea of overblown vanity productions. There's no slack evident in the tight wordplays of Def and Kweli as they twist and turn through sparse, jazz-rooted rhythms calling out for awareness and freedom of the mind. Their viewpoints stem directly from the teachings of Marcus Garvey, the legendary activist who fought for the rights of blacks all around the world in the first half of the 20th century. Def and Kweli's ideals are sure lofty; not only are they out to preach Garvey's words, but they also hope to purge rap music of its negativity and violence. For the most part, it works. Their wisdom-first philosophy hits hard when played off their lyrical intensity, a bass-first production, and stellar scratching. While these MCs don't have all of the vocal pizzazz of A Tribe Called Quest's Phife andQ-Tip at their best, flawless tracks like the cool bop of "K.O.S. (Determination)" and "Definition" hint thatBlack Star is only the first of many brilliantly executed positive statements for these two street poets."

http://www.allmusic.com/album/black-star-mw0000043603

Sunday, February 10, 2013

Why We Study "The Bluest Eye"


                                                                                                February 10th, 2013
Dear Language and Literature Students,
As your English teacher, I want to start a discussion to a question received from a student: “As a teacher, why do you think this book should be read and discussed in school? Why did you pick this book for us to read?” at a practical level before turning my attention to the deeper, literary value of studying a text as shocking as "The Bluest Eye."
As an English Department, we are given a choice to select texts we believe will fire students’ imaginations from the IB’s Prescribed List of Authors/ Prescribed List in Translation for the English A: Language and Literature course. Toni Morrison, as a Nobel Prize-winning author, is on this list. What she provides is a black, female voice from America who has lived/written throughout the course of the Civil Rights Movement. For someone like me--from a white, middle-class background, who is a teacher at an international school-- it is of crucial importance that there is a balance of male/female voices from different ethnicities available to students. Of course, we are also somewhat limited to the class texts that are in the book cupboard too!

I admit to feeling discomfort with the topics presented within the novel and had to debate whether I thought it would be suitable for Grade 11 students. I decided that it would be, as although this is an text with some very adult issues, it offers us a chance to understand the power of language and the function of literature as a vehicle for conveying deep-rooted, upsetting, sociological problems. As a Diploma level class, I believe, we have to challenge ourselves to become aware of the gross-inequalities/abuses that can exist within societies and “give a voice to the voiceless.” Literature offers us a point of access from a fictional perspective to address issues that may otherwise be left 'swept under the carpet'. In writing this novel, Morrison discomforts the reader and makes them sit up and take notice, potentially to take action, against moral wrongs that have been allowed to occur in society due to hatred or indifference.

To understand Morrison’s motivation for writing as a black, female author, we must first understand the extent of exploitation that occurred within American Society (the setting of this novel is America, the theme of exploitation is global) with regard to slavery. In her Nobel Prize for Literature acceptance speech in 1993, Morrison refers to the words of Abraham Lincoln in his famous Gettysburg Address, when he states that, “"The world will little note nor long remember what we say here. But it will never forget what they did here." Morrison admires his simple words as “exhilarating in their life-sustaining properties because they refused to encapsulate the reality of 600, 000 dead men in a cataclysmic race war.” The 600,000 dead in this case are the soldiers of the Union and Confederate armies (although the actual figure is hard to know for certain). Morrison is making a link that the legacy of slavery, which was responsible for the deaths of countless more (we cannot be sure of the exact number as they were considered sub-human) is a sore on the conscience of society which must be confronted, and cannot be run away from.

I believe she writes this text as an allegory of the horrifying oppression that black people suffered, and especially black females, as they occupied an even lower place within society. While Lincoln’s 1863 “Emancipation Proclamation” may seem like ancient history, it really is not so long ago that slavery existed within the 'first world'. To a greater extent we should also recognize that Morrison is documenting a time, in the 1950s, which was a decade ahead of Martin Luther King’s Civil Rights Movement and black people were subjected to terrible inequalities and abuses, some of which are mentioned within the text and are reason for Cholly’s descent from someone who wins the reader’s sympathy (this is a contestable point) to someone who later rapes his daughter.

My regret is that students reading this text for a summer assignment are confronted first with the vulgar, upsetting sequence of events, without having the support of activities such as class discussions, which would allow for a deeper connection to the allegorical nature of the text. Unfortunately, that is the nature of setting a text to read over the summer break—a necessity due to the structure of the school year—and I would certainly welcome a discussion in class upon our return to understand how best to introduce this text to both minimize discomfort, but also to ensure that engagement is not lost by giving away the content of the work beforehand.

If the issues as they have been presented in this letter are of interest, then for further study I would highly recommend you to watch Professor Hungerford’s Yale University lecture within the following clip. It is 50 minutes long but well worth the time and would be very interesting for you to see how literature is analyzed at university level: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7NUCOLCcXCY. Additionally, I would recommend you listening to Toni Morrison herself speaking to the Nobel Committee as she accepted her award for “The Bluest Eye.” Here are the links to the text/audio of that speech. Listen very carefully and I think her moral of ‘The bird-in-the-hand’ could stimulate your perception of language, literature, education and moral responsibility.


I look forward to developing these ideas as a class in a couple of weeks. Wishing you all a pleasant end to your summer vacation, and remember to ensure that all summer tasks are up-to-date upon your return (check Moodle for details).

Regards,

Mr. Rees


Toni Morrison’s 1993 Nobel Prize for Literature acceptance speech: audio

http://www.nobelprize.org/mediaplayer/index.php?id=1502

Toni Morrison’s 1993 Nobel Prize for Literature acceptance speech: text

http://www.nobelprize.org/nobel_prizes/literature/laureates/1993/morrison-lecture.html


“Fiction has never been entertainment.”  A poignant, though challenging speech on the complexities of language and how essential it is to seek truth through fiction, and reject the limiting, oppressive language of those who wield power without responsibility. 

Wednesday, February 6, 2013

The Bluest Eye, by Toni Morrison


“The Bluest Eye”, by Toni Morrison.

Notes on Part One: “Autumn”.

n  Response to the style/structure of the opening chapters preceding “Autumn”.





“Autumn”

p.16: Mr. Henry arrives/Pecola arrives

p.20—doll description

p.27—Pecola’s menstruation


Characters

Pecola—“She came with nothing.” –p.18; p.43: “She struggled with an overwhelming desire that one would kill the other and a profound wish that she herself would die.”/ p. 45: “Please God, make me disappear….Only her tight, tight eyes were left.”/ p.46: “It occurred to Pecola that if …her eyes were beautiful... she herself would be different.”

Pecola’s father

Protagonist—9 yrs

Protagonist’s sister Frieda—10 yrs.

Mrs. MacTeer. Protagonist’s mother—p.24 “My mother’s fussing soliloquies always  irritated and depressed us”; “She would burst into song and sing all day.” Fusses about the here quarts of milk.  P.26: Morrison develops her vernacular tone of voice as she complains about her poverty. She beats the girls upon Rosemary’s informing her that they are “playing nasty” without even asking for an explanation. Contradictory though as she then holds the girls’ heads to her stomach in a very tender way.

Rosemary Villanuci—Next-door ‘friend’ offers “to pull her pants down” to stop beating from sisters.

Mr. Henry Washington—“our roomer”. Older, not young. Not married. A “steady worker”. Humorous and charming when he meets the girls “You must be Greta Garbot..”

Miss Della Jones—Mr. Henry’s previous crazed landlady

Old Slack Bettie—Madame

Peggy—One of OSB’s girls who ran off with Della Jones’  husband.

Cholly ‘Old Dog’ Breedlove—having put his family outdoors (worst thing you can do—p.17) “an old dog, a snake, a ratty nigger”.  Does not come to visit his daughter even after being released from jail. Whisky drinker.

Mrs. Breedlove—staying with the woman she was working for. Has one twisted foot.

Sammy Breedlove—with another family. p.43: “He was known, by the time he was fourteen, to have run away from home no less than twenty-seven times.”; p.44: “Sammy screamed, “Kill him! Kill him!”/

Three Whores: China, Poland and Miss Marie. They live above Pecola and are only ones to offer her kindness.  Three merry gargoyles. Their conversations are amusing and provide some light relief…but the humor is dark as they remember failed relationships and missed opportunities. They are economically empowered to some degree though. They use men for their own gain. “These women hated men, all men,, without exception.”

Relationships between characters:

Protagonist hates Pecola at first. “Unsullied hatred.” –p.19

Style

Ironic. Deadpan.  Shocks reader with unexpected undercurrent of violence; “Our house is old, cold and green”—basic vocabulary of narrator reflects her lack of education and the barren nature of her environment; “Adults do not talk to us—they give us directions.” –alienating view of ‘parents’;  use of dialogue (p.13) that develops ‘gossipy’ nature of the environment; humor is also conveyed in dialogue; crucially the girls only overhear descriptions of these people; there is little direct communication between parent/child and when there is it is admonishment for being sick and therefore unable to work; musical descriptions of conversation—p.15; sensory description of smell of Mr. Henry—sensual; ominous sensuality—the girls put their hands all over Mr. Henry as they search for the magically disappeared penny;

Semantics: “There was a difference between put out and being outdoors.” –p.17

Animalistic imagery: ““an old dog, a snake, a ratty nigger”—p.19


Setting:

1939 Buick; Zick’s Coal Company; food shortages; pick up pieces of coal from industrial railway line; poverty; school; “Our house is old, cold and green.”—Para. 2 of p.10.  Next to a coal works; $2.50/week –a “big help” to the family

p. 33: “There is an abandoned store on the southeast corner of Broadway andThirty-fifth Street in Lorain, Ohio.” –used to be a pizza parlor, a bakers and a house for gypsies. There was a fluid population in this part of the city. BREEDLOVES’ HOUSE and they lived there anonymously.

p.35: “There is nothing more to say about the furnishings… They had all been… manufactured… in  various stages of thoughtlessness, greed and indifference.”

p.25: “Roosevelt and the CCC camps.”

Pervasive cold.


Narrative Voice: “But was it really like that? As painful as I remember? Only mildly.”—this is a narrative vice that reflects on the past.

p.12—“Our roomer. Our roomer.” –repetition reflects the confusion of the girls at the time who did not understand who this man coming to live with them was.

p.15-“…their conversation is like a gently wicked dance.”

p.22—says she does not want to possess the baby doll—contradicts herself.

p.23: Sadistic—transferred violence. “If I pinched them, their eyes—unlike the crazed glint of the baby doll’s eyes—would fold in pain.”

p.48: Third-person-limited voice of Pecola delivered in a stream-of-consciousness style allows us to experience the world from her perspective

Themes:

n  Economic disadvantage—had they not been a poor family, they would not need to accept a roomer and then…. ; p.38: “(The Breedlove’s) lived there because they were black and stayed there because they believed they were ugly.” They were convinced of their own ugliness (probably forced upon them by Cholly’s abusive behavior).

n  Ownership: p.48/49: “She owned the crack that made her stumble. She owned the clumps of dandelions , whose white heads, last fall, she had blown away… and owning them made her part of the world, and the world a part of her.  The things that Pecola ‘owns’ are imaginary but gives her something real for her to hold on to.

n  Escapism: p.46/start of each chapter. The (moronic) repetitive chanting of the idealized white world. “Pretty eyes. Pretty blue eyes. Big blue pretty eyes.”

n  Relationship between the State and the individual/family: p.16 “The county had placed her in our house...”; “She just came with a white woman and then sat down.” –p.18;

n  American Dream (dissolved?); p.17 “(poverty) breeds a hunger for property, for ownership”;  p.39: “On Saturday morning, one by one, the family slipped out of their dreams of affluence and misery  into the anaonymous misery of their storefront.”

n  Disillusionment of authority figures: p. 21—“Tears threatened to erase the aloofness of their authority.”

n  Racial inferiority: p.22: “What made people look at them and say, ‘Awwww’, but not for me?”

n  Men’s mistreatment of women.  Violent domestic relationships. P.40: Cholly had come home too drunk to fight. (later that morning)…the fight would lack spontaneity; it would b calculated, uninspired and deadly.”

n  Ironic/sardonic view of religion. P.42.

Structure: Intriguing statements which refer to later events creating dramatic tension: p. 16: “We loved him. Even after what came later…”

Important Quotations:

p. 17 “Outdoors, we knew, was the real terror of life. The threat of being outdoors surfaced frequently in those days.”

“…a minority in both class and caste.”

p.19 “It had begun with Christmas and the gift of dolls.”

p.22: “I destroyed white baby dolls.”

p.41: “You say one more word and I’ll split you open.”

p.42: “The flashlight did not move. For some reason, Cholly had not hated the white men; he hated, despised, the girl.”

p.42: “She needed Cholly’s sins desperately. The lower he sank, the wilder and more irresponsible he became, the more splendid she and her task became. In the name of Jesus.”

p.43: “Don’t, Mrs. Breedlove. Don’t”

p.46: “Every night, without fail she prayed for blue eyes.”

p.48: “How can a fifty-two-year-old white immigrant store-keeper…see a little black girl?”/ “She looks up at him and sees the vacuum where curiosity ought to lodge. And something more. The total absence of human recognition—the glazed separatedness.”

Symbols:

p.35 Pervasive crapulence of the sofa that dominates the house.

p. 36: “The fire seemed to live, go down, or die, according to its own schemata. In the morning however, it always seemed fit to die.”

Motifs:

Flowers:

Marigolds: p.5. “We thought, at the time, that it was because Pecola was having her father’s baby that the marigolds did not grow.”/Dandelions: p.49. “Dandelions. A dart of affection leaps out from her to them.  But they do not look at her and do not send love back.”

Sweets:

p.50: “To eat the candy is somehow to eat the eyes, eat Mary Jane. Love Mary Jane. Be Mary Jane.”

Colors:

Black: p.49. “So, the distaste must be for her, her blackness… But her blackness is static and dread.”

Music: Pecola’s mother’s songs. The blues songs of Poland.

Activities:

Very close study of opening chapters that leads to close literary analysis and establishing key aspects of the text: setting; style; characters; themes; symbols/motifs etc.

p.13: “That old nigger…” –refer to “The Meaning of Nigger” essay

p.15-“…their conversation is like a gently wicked dance.”—listen to black people talking (do we have a video?)

p.20-22: Analyze baby doll passage. –have someone bring in a baby doll.

p.35: Mapping the Breedlove’s House.

Explain who Ginger Rogers and Greta Garbot are.